If we start with charities’ needs rather than our own organisations, some potentially uncomfortable questions follow. Do we all need to do everything? Does every national, local and specialist infrastructure organisation need its own training offer, digital resources, leadership programmes and policy function? Probably not.
The organisations proposing the independent review have acknowledged this themselves. The infrastructure landscape has evolved organisation by organisation, creating overlapping remits, competition for members and funders and, for smaller charities trying to find support, considerable complexity.
The recent experiences of Reach Volunteering, Directory of Social Change and CAF make the need to think differently particularly urgent. Reach came within weeks of closing after 45 years before nine funders stepped in to support it until the end of 2028. DSC has entered insolvency. CAF is in redundancy consultations with its staff. Other infrastructure organisations, including Children England, the Foundation for Social Improvement, the Small Charities Coalition and Getting On Board, have already disappeared.
So we should be much more deliberate about where specialist expertise adds value, where local relationships are indispensable and where sharing capability would produce better outcomes than duplicating it.
Ultimately, infrastructure should reduce duplication in the sector, not inadvertently create another layer of it.
That’s why Media Trust is partnering with NCVO to convene a roundtable on Building an AI-confident Third Sector, bringing together organisations working across charity infrastructure, digital capability, funding and technology.
We want to map where there are overlaps and where there are gaps in AI support for the wider sector.